CAFC Affirms Dismissals of Patent Infringement Lawsuits Against Apple, Amazon Web Services and Netflix

“In other words, Ziklag’s request to amend was made in bad faith.” – CAFC

CAFCThe U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC), in two rulings issued today in Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Netflix, Inc. and Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Apple Inc. and Amazon Web Services, Inc., affirmed decisions of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois dismissing infringement claims Ziklag IP LLC asserted on an expired patent. In the Netflix appeal, the CAFC found no abuse of discretion in the district court’s refusal to allow Ziklag to return the original patent owner, Touchmusic, to the case. In the two appeals involving Apple and Amazon Web Services, Inc. (AWS), the CAFC held that Ziklag was collaterally estopped from contesting a ruling that it never received the right to sue for past damages. Circuit Judge Stoll wrote for the court in each appeal, joined by Circuit Judges Lourie and Stark, and affirmed the district court’s judgments.

The litigation centered on U.S. Patent No. 6,182,128, which expired on March 5, 2018. In March 2024, Touchmusic filed separate lawsuits against Apple, AWS, and Netflix alleging infringement of the ‘128 patent while its corporate rights were suspended under California law, and Touchmusic therefore lacked capacity to bring suit. On April 18, 2024, Touchmusic assigned certain rights in the ‘128 patent to Ziklag, a newly formed Tennessee entity, and amended its complaints to substitute Ziklag in Touchmusic’s place.

Judge Mary M. Rowland, who presided over the Netflix case, granted Netflix’s motion to dismiss on March 25, 2025, finding that Ziklag lacked the right to sue for past infringement and that this deficiency was fatal since the patent had expired. Ziklag then argued that returning Touchmusic to the case would cure the problem, since Touchmusic had retained the right to sue for past damages and its corporate status had been restored. On June 20, 2025, the district court denied leave to amend and dismissed with prejudice, finding that the original substitution was “not due to an honest mistake but was done for tactical advantage to avoid the issue of Touchmusic’s suspended corporate status.”

The CAFC applied Seventh Circuit law, since the denial of leave to amend is not unique to patent law, and reviewed the ruling for abuse of discretion. Ziklag contended that it did not have an opportunity to brief the dispositive question. The CAFC disagreed, and observed that Netflix had opposed amendment in its motion to dismiss briefing, that the district court’s first order discussed Rule 17, and that the district court had set a hearing and further briefing on amendment. “Ziklag had ample opportunity to address amending the complaint,” Judge Stoll wrote.

Ziklag also argued that the district court erred by analyzing its request under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 17 instead of Rule 15(a). The CAFC, citing Lans v. Digital Equipment Corp., explained that Rule 17(a)(3) guards against forfeiture where identifying the proper party is difficult or where an understandable mistake occurred. The CAFC saw no abuse of discretion in the district court’s finding that Ziklag had not made an understandable mistake and held that “[t]he district court did not abuse its discretion in applying Rule 17.” Even under Rule 15(a), the CAFC found no abuse of discretion, explaining that the district court’s finding that the substitution was made for tactical advantage was effectively a finding of bad faith, and that Seventh Circuit precedent permits denial of amendment on that basis. “In other words, Ziklag’s request to amend was made in bad faith,” the CAFC said.

In the separate Apple and AWS cases, Judge Steven C. Seeger agreed with AWS on March 31, 2025, that Touchmusic never assigned Ziklag the right to sue for past damages and dismissed the claims against AWS and Apple with prejudice. On appeal, Ziklag asked the CAFC to decide whether an assignee of an expired patent may sue for past infringement when the written assignment does not expressly convey that right. The CAFC ordered supplemental briefing limited to collateral estoppel and determined that question before any other.

Under the Seventh Circuit test set out in Adair v. Sherman, collateral estoppel requires that the issue be the same as one in a prior action and that it was actually litigated. The determination must also have been essential to the final judgment, and the party against whom estoppel is invoked must have been represented in the earlier action. Ziklag did not dispute the second through fourth requirements. In a footnote, the CAFC rejected Ziklag’s description of the Netflix assignment determination as an “interlocutory ruling,” noting that Judge Rowland could not have reached the amendment question without first deciding the assignment issue.

Ziklag relied on Innovad and Cygnus to argue that the separate Netflix proceeding should not bar review. “This appeal is distinguishable from Innovad and Cygnus,” the CAFC said, explaining that the claims in those cases arose within a single multi-defendant proceeding with no separate first action. Touchmusic filed separate complaints that were not consolidated, the Netflix case was before a different judge, and the Netflix assignment ruling came six days before the Apple and AWS dismissals. Ziklag also did not ask Apple or AWS to waive preclusion.

A reversal on the merits, the CAFC added, would produce a result in which “two entities would simultaneously own an undivided right to sue for past damages,” an inconsistency the CAFC said collateral estoppel is intended to prevent, citing Allen v. McCurry. The CAFC did not reach the merits of the assignment question.

Ultimately, the CAFC affirmed the Northern District of Illinois’ denial of leave to amend and dismissal with prejudice in the Netflix case, and affirmed the dismissals with prejudice of Ziklag’s claims against Apple and AWS.

Image Source: Deposit Photos
Image ID: 103763568
Copyright: bigfatnapoleon 

Share

Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author as of the time of publication and should not be attributed to the author’s employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com.

Join the Discussion

No comments yet. Add my comment.

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Varsity Sponsors

From the IPWatchdog Institute

IPWatchdog Events

IPWatchdog LIVE 2027 at the Renaissance Arlington Capital View
April 4, 2027 @ 1:00 pm - April 6, 2027 @ 7:00 pm EDT
Women’s IP Forum 2027
September 8, 2027 @ 8:00 am - September 10, 2027 @ 5:00 pm EDT
Patent Masters™ 2027
October 6, 2027 @ 8:00 am - October 8, 2027 @ 5:00 pm EDT

From IPWatchdog