“Innovaport’s cert petition argued that cases relied upon by the Federal Circuit for evading deference to USPTO eligibility determinations do not allow such eligibility determinations to be completely disregarded.”
Today, the U.S. Supreme Court issued an order list including denials of a pair of petitions for writ of certiorari challenging subject matter eligibility analyses under 35 U.S.C. § 101 by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. These denials continue the Court’s trend of ignoring loud alarms raised regarding the Federal Circuit’s application of the Court’s two-step patentability test under Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International, especially the intra-circuit development of conflicting standards for analyzing subject matter eligibility of computer-related inventions.
Innovaport v. Target Corp.: CAFC Ignored Preemption Arguments in Finding Ineligibility
Founded by electrical engineer and patent attorney John Pienkos, Innovaport pursued licensing opportunities with big-box retailers for Pienkos’ invention of a means for assisting customers to locate items within a store. After Target built its own product location system, Innovaport filed suit in the Western District of Wisconsin asserting claims from six patents claiming priority to the same provisional patent application filed in 1999. Of the patents-in-suit, two were issued by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) after overcoming examiner objections to patentability under Section 101.
The Western Wisconsin district court entered summary judgment for Target after finding that Innovaport’s patent claims were invalid under Section 101. This ruling was affirmed by the Federal Circuit, which held Innovaport’s claims directed to the abstract idea of analyzing, customizing and displaying information at Step 1 of the Alice test, then found at Step 2 that linking two products in a cross-referential manner and providing product recommendations are abstract ideas, not inventive concepts.
Innovaport’s cert petition argued that cases relied upon by the Federal Circuit for evading deference to USPTO eligibility determinations do not allow such eligibility determinations to be completely disregarded. In the obviousness context, Innovaport notes that consideration of the asserted prior art by the USPTO examiner leads to a particularly strong presumption of validity under 35 U.S.C. § 282. Relying on Sanderling Management v. Snap’s (2023) language on deference to render the USPTO’s eligibility determination moot raises public policy issues as to whether patentees can rely upon agency eligibility guidance, Innovaport contended.
While Alice reaffirmed the importance of preemption when considering abstractness, Innovaport’s cert petition stated that the CAFC ignored arguments that its patent claims were narrowly tailored. For example, Innovaport pointed to the claimed “information storage device” of U.S. Patent No. 9489690, one of Innovaport’s two asserted patents overcoming Section 101 rejections at the USPTO, which provides the location of products suggested based on a consumer’s past purchases. Granting cert would have allowed the Supreme Court to clarify that preemption must be substantively evaluated under Alice Step 1, Innovaport’s cert petition argued.
The Supreme Court could also have clarified that the Federal Circuit’s 2016 Enfish v. Microsoft Corp. ruling does not require computer-related patent claims to improve computer functioning at Alice Step 1. Innovaport argued that under Section 101’s requirement that an invention be “useful,” its invention provides real-world benefits, including a more efficient shopping experience at lower cost with less employee involvement. Further, the Federal Circuit failed to cite record evidence supporting its finding at Alice Step 2 that the claim elements were well-understood, routine or conventional, blurring lines with the court’s Step 1 analysis in a manner that was recently identified by the petition for cert in US Patent No. 7,679,637 LLC v. Google, which was also denied by the Court this October.
Oasis Tooling v. Siemens Industry Software: Intra-Circuit McRO/PersonalWeb Split Requires SCOTUS Intervention
Issues with the Federal Circuit’s Section 101 analysis in the context of computer-based inventions was also the focus of Oasis Tooling’s cert petition filed this October. Oasis Tooling’s patents cover processes for analyzing semiconductor chip designs that identify cells that are functionally the same even if expressed differently by the chip design language. Although Oasis Tooling argued that such identification was impossible by conventional means, the District of Delaware granted summary judgment of Section 101 patent ineligibility, finding the elimination of white space as non-functional variation between semiconductor design files directed to an unpatentable mental process. The Federal Circuit, while conceding that “human minds are unable to” perform the patented analysis steps, nevertheless affirmed this February.
Oasis Tooling’s cert petition argued that an intra-circuit split has developed at the Federal Circuit with one line of cases following McRO v. Bandai Namco Games America (2016) asking whether the claimed process differs from the prior conventional human process, whereas several other cases including PersonalWeb Technologies v. Google (2021) that have found patents ineligible under Section 101 when the function is generally accomplishable by the human mind even when the specific claimed steps are not.
This irreconcilable conflict in case law was deepened by the CAFC’s decision below, according to Oasis Tooling, because it clearly acknowledged the human mind’s inability to parse data as called for by the patented claims. While the human mind compares chip designs visually, the claimed invention requires partitioning data into header and cell portions, atomizing chip design to its smallest components, and hashing data to create a numerical string representing the functional design. The Federal Circuit’s exclusive jurisdiction over patent appeals makes the intra-circuit split particularly pernicious, with Oasis Tooling citing the fractured en banc rehearing denial issued by the Federal Circuit in Athena Diagnostics v. Mayo Collaborative Services (2019) as proof that the Supreme Court’s intervention is required.
Image Source: Deposit Photos
Author: hafid007
Image ID: 453186314

Join the Discussion
No comments yet. Add my comment.
Add Comment