“Netlist misconceives the law of obviousness.” – Federal Circuit
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) issued a precedential decision on Friday, November 13, in In re Netlist, Inc., affirming the Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB) determination that all challenged claims of two Netlist memory module patents are unpatentable as obvious. Circuit Judge Dyk wrote for the court, joined by Circuit Judges Linn and Chen, and rejected Netlist’s argument that the PTAB erred in finding a motivation to combine since the combination would be inoperable for the intended purpose of the primary reference and would lose that reference’s key benefits.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Micron Technology, Inc., Micron Semiconductor Products, Inc., and Micron Technology Texas, LLC challenged all claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215 in four inter partes review (IPR) proceedings, IPR2023-00454, IPR2023-00455, IPR2023-01141, and IPR2023-01142. The two patents, each titled “Memory Module with Data Buffering,” share substantially identical specifications and concern a computer memory module with buffer circuitry between the memory devices and the computer’s memory controller. The buffer separates the ranks of memory devices and reduces the load on the computer system, although it can also add timing delay. Claim 1 of the ‘417 patent recites a module that uses chip select signals, and Netlist agreed that the claims of the two patents did not materially differ for purposes of the appeal.
According to the opinion, JEDEC and Rambus specifications take different approaches to selecting memory chips, with JEDEC relying on chip select signals and Rambus relying on unique device identifiers. The obviousness ground at issue combined Perego (U.S. Patent No. 7,363,422), which discloses a buffer device on a memory module, with JESD79-2, a JEDEC specification for DDR2 SDRAM published in September 2003 that supplies the chip select signals Perego did not specifically disclose.
In its final written decision of July 30, 2024, the PTAB found that the combination of Perego and JESD79-2 disclosed every limitation of claim 1, a finding Netlist did not challenge on appeal. The PTAB found a motivation to combine based on Perego’s suggestion of alternative embodiments compatible with JEDEC standards, including bussed topologies, Perego’s emphasis on flexibility and the ability to upgrade across many module configurations, and the dominance of JEDEC-compliant modules in the market at the relevant time. The PTAB held all challenged claims unpatentable as obvious and did not reach the other asserted grounds.
Samsung settled with Netlist and filed a notice of nonparticipation before oral argument, and the Micron entities settled and withdrew after argument. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) declined to intervene. The Federal Circuit, citing In re Rambus, held that “a live controversy regarding the patentability of Netlist’s claims remains before us for resolution.”
Netlist argued on appeal that Perego was built for the Rambus architecture and that the combination with JESD79-2 would make Perego non-functional for Rambus and would cause it to lose backward compatibility. Netlist relied on In re Gordon, maintaining that these consequences defeated the motivation to combine.
According to the CAFC, “Netlist misconceives the law of obviousness.” The opinion cited KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc. for the principle that common items can have evident uses beyond their primary purposes. It further explained that the obviousness inquiry focuses on whether a skilled artisan would have had reason to combine the references to achieve the claimed invention. The combination does not need to satisfy the requirements of the first reference. In a motivation to combine analysis, “the intended purpose of [the prior art] does not control,” the CAFC said, but instead, “what matters is whether a skilled artisan would have had an adequate reason to modify Perego” so that it would work with JEDEC standards.
The Federal Circuit distinguished Gordon, in which the claim was directed to a blood filter assembly with inlet and outlet ports at the bottom, and the prior art was a gasoline filter with ports at the top that relied on gravity to separate lighter gasoline from denser contaminants. In Gordon, the prior art’s own functionality supplied the motivation to combine, and inverting the prior art filter would have made it inoperable for its intended purpose. Polaris, Medtronic, and Chemourseach involved a defeated purpose shared with the claimed invention, while Netlist’s case involved no shared purpose. Rambus compatibility and backward compatibility with Rambus were not purposes of Netlist’s claimed invention, which is directed to operating within a JEDEC-compliant architecture. Netlist also did not argue that Perego itself supplied the motivation to combine. In a footnote, the CAFC rejected Netlist’s Administrative Procedure Act (APA) argument, noting that the PTAB had addressed the backward compatibility passage from Perego.
The CAFC held that substantial evidence supported the PTAB’s motivation findings. The PTAB found that Perego disclosed “bussed topologies” as alternatives to the Rambus point-to-point link, 64-bit modules wider than the Rambus maximum of 36 bits, and row and column address strobe lines used in JEDEC architectures. The PTAB also relied on Perego’s emphasis on upgradeability and flexibility across module types, as well as Netlist’s own expert testimony, which showed that JEDEC-compliant modules were dominant in the market at the relevant time. Ultimately, Netlist did not contest that dominance or that the combination was JEDEC capable.
Image Source: Deposit Photos
Image ID: 213063766
Author: Devon
Join the Discussion
No comments yet. Add my comment.
Add Comment