“The claims provide no guidance whatsoever on how to measure MVTR.” – Federal Circuit
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) issued a precedential decision Tuesday in Cocona, Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, affirming a judgment of the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado that held three claims of a waterproof, breathable membrane patent invalid as indefinite. Circuit Judge Stark wrote for the court, joined by Circuit Judges Lourie and Stoll, and agreed with the district court that the asserted claims recited a numerical range for moisture vapor transmission rate (MVTR) without specifying a method for measuring it.
Cocona, Inc. filed a lawsuit against VF Outdoor, LLC, which does business as The North Face, and Columbia Sportswear Company, alleging infringement of U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287. The ‘287 patent, titled “Active Particle-Enhanced Membrane and Methods for Making and Using the Same,” covers a membrane that incorporates active particles, such as activated carbon, to improve vapor transmission and odor absorption.
VF Outdoor petitioned the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) for inter partes review (IPR) of claims 27-28, 30, 32-33, and 35-39. The PTAB found every challenged claim except claims 38 and 39 unpatentable as obvious, and the CAFC affirmed that decision in 2021. Litigation in the district court then proceeded on claims 1, 38, and 39, each of which requires “a moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day.” Cocona proposed construing that limitation to require testing under the ASTM E96 cup water method at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over 24 hours, with the upright method used for low moisture contact and the inverted method used for high moisture contact. The district court rejected the proposal, held the asserted claims indefinite, and entered judgment for VF Outdoor and Columbia.
On de novo review, the claims set out an MVTR range yet say nothing about which testing approach applies, which cup method to use, or what temperature and humidity conditions to apply. Judge Stark agreed with the district court that “the claims provide no guidance whatsoever on how to measure MVTR.”
The specification identifies three measurement approaches, the Mocon method, an upright cup method for low moisture contact, and an inverted cup method for high moisture contact, but does not explain how to tell low moisture contact apart from high moisture contact. Only one embodiment, Example 1, appears in the patent, and it states that MVTR “may be measured” under ASTM E96-94 at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity. The CAFC described that wording as permissive and noted that the ASTM standard itself allows a range of temperature and humidity conditions. Although Cocona, VF Outdoor, and Columbia disagreed over whether Mocon qualifies as a separate method, the court reached the same conclusion assuming only two methods were available.
The CAFC also examined test results reported in the patent and its provisional application. In Figure 2 of the ‘287 patent, a control sample without active particles measured 470 g/m2/day under the upright method, below the claimed range, and 6,356 g/m2/day under the inverted method. Table 2 of the provisional application showed sample 41-6-4 measuring 1,394 g/m2/day with the inverted method and 223 g/m2/day with the upright method by placing the same sample inside or outside the range depending on the method selected. Table 2, according to the opinion, “would clearly leave a person of ordinary skill in the art lacking reasonable certainty.”
Under Dow Chemical Co. v. Nova Chemicals Corp., Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc., and Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., the CAFC held that the presence of “multiple methods leading to different results without guidance in the patent” means that “a person of ordinary skill in the art lacks reasonable certainty as to claim scope.” Judge Stark wrote that the holding applies “in the specific context of the ‘287 patent,” adding that “we are not holding, as Cocona fears, that the MVTR Limitation is per se indefinite.”
Cocona contended that Figure 2 and Table 2 were irrelevant since the tested samples did not practice the claims. Even assuming that premise, the CAFC reasoned, different results from different methods remain relevant to indefiniteness. Cocona also relied on Presidio Components, Inc. v. American Technical Ceramics Corp. and Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc., which the court distinguished. Presidio involved a single established measurement method, while Ethicon’s specification provided enough guidance to choose among methods.
Furthermore, Cocona maintained that the 40-degree and 20% humidity conditions in Example 1 controlled the measurement. The CAFC disagreed, treating those figures “as non-mandatory examples of testing conditions.”
Cocona separately argued that the district court applied an incorrect legal standard by requiring mandatory language in the patent. The CAFC, citing Akamai Technologies, Inc. v. MediaPointe, Inc., agreed that “patents containing permissive language and discretionary words may survive indefiniteness challenges.” The district court, however, articulated the correct standard and applied it to the totality of the evidence, and its passing references to mandatory guidelines and imperative language did not demonstrate that it applied an overly strict standard.
The district court credited Dr. Abigail Oelker’s declaration over Dr. Stephen McCarthy’s testimony, which it found conclusory, and the CAFC found no clear error. The CAFC rejected Cocona’s argument that Dr. Oelker’s IPR testimony was inconsistent with her declaration, explaining that the earlier testimony addressed MVTR values of prior art membranes rather than how a skilled artisan would read the measurement methods in the ‘287 patent.
Ultimately, the CAFC affirmed the district court’s judgment that claims 1, 38, and 39 of the ‘287 patent are invalid as indefinite.
Image Source: Deposit Photos
Author: NiceIdeas
Image ID: 421287828

Join the Discussion
No comments yet. Add my comment.
Add Comment